S
Stephanie Oldeck
August 26, 2025
A forbidden romance that gives you allllll the feels
Oh, my goodness, this book was well worth the wait! Theo is struggling to come to terms with the fact his dad not only married his affair partner but also made his biggest rival his new stepbrother. Madden is infuriatingly composed and seems to buy into the new family dynamic without hesitation, which just makes Theo hate him more. And on top of that, the mandatory "family" vacation leaves Theo and Madden having to make nice. With Madden somehow landing in his pocket every time he turns around, Theo is over the whole situation. Except there is a draw towards Madden that he's having an even bigger time resisting, one that leads to a scorching kiss he can't get out of his head. With baseball season coming up, Theo knows it's stupid to get involved with a rival, but spending time with Madden seems to bring out the best in Theo, and he can't deny that Madden is everything he has always wanted. But with his friends breathing down his neck, Theo has to decide what he wants more, to win the school rivalry game and appease his friends, or Madden and everything good that he sees in Theo. As a wise person once said, when it's forever on the line, you have to break all the rules. And as far as Theo is concerned, when it comes to Madden, there's not a single rule he wouldn't break to keep him.
I can't believe how much I loved this book. (I mean, I can, because all of CE Ricci's books are amazing). But it came so close to pushing Caught Stealing out of the top spot. I loved Madden so…