K
Katherine Hunter
January 25, 2025
Verified Purchase
A creative adventure book with sea creatures, swordfights and a bright psychedelic treasure island.
The Adventures of Amina al-Sarafi is a swashbuckling tale about a middle-aged, retired female pirate, who is given the opportunity of one final adventure. The story is set around the trade routes and towns on the coast of the Indian Ocean in the 12th century.
When the wealthy mother of a former crewman tracks Amina down with the task of locating her missing daughter, Amina quickly seizes the opportunity to head back to sea on her beloved ship, the Marawati. She assembles her old team—Dalila (The Mistress of Poisons), Tinbu (a sailor) and Majed (the navigator). Soon enough, Amina and her crew discover that their adventure will be more dangerous than they thought: the ‘Frank’ (Historically the Latin Christians of Western Europe), Falco, that they are up against is not only an infamous bandit, but also has magical powers that could lead to the end of the humankind. He is after The Moon of Saba, a magical artifact that, in the hands of the wrong person, could wreak havoc.
This was a fun, imaginative read with a unique premise. How often do you read about what happens after a character completes their hero's journey and retires? Not to mention, the location of the story is also truly special. How refreshing to read a book that takes place in the Islamic East, instead of the average Western locations! And, while the book starts a bit slow, the ending is, truly, an adventure!
The other settings in the book were also amazing, and probably my favorite part of the book. Chakraborty…
A great female pirate adventure
A great female pirate adventure story that touched into the supernatural. A descriptively beautiful world was created from the story and I liked how it was done as a recounting of her tales to a scribe. I loved finding out who the scribe was at the end of the story.
My biggest complaint with the story had nothing to do with the story itself, but rather with the narration on the audible copy. There were parts where the scribe interrupts the story and then Amina turns to talk to the scribe directly. These parts are so quiet and muffled on the audio that I missed what was being said. Even turning my volume up to full blast, wasn't enough to fully understand it. I ended up checking out the hardcover version from the library so that I could go back and read the missed parts, which distracted me from the story. I likely would have enjoyed the story even more without the interruption parts.
My fave character of the tale was Recsh (sp?) as he was truly a diverse and unique character, who while painted to be the villain in the story, was actually more than not. He was selfish for sure, but he must have cared for Amina as well as he does end up helping and saving her quite a few times.
I would love to read more stories set in this world, as long as the cast of characters remained the same, as they are what made the story enjoyable. They were all such a mish-mash of people who didn't belong together, but when together made such a harmonious crew.
Glad that my book club finally…
K
KimberlyM
November 14, 2025
Verified Purchase
Fast-paced, original, and consistently entertaining
The Adventures of Amina al-Sirafi follows a retired, middle-aged pirate who is hiding from an old enemy to protect her young daughter. Her quiet life unravels when a wealthy woman tracks her down and coerces her into taking on one last job: finding the woman’s kidnapped granddaughter. Amina reunites with her old crew and sets off on what should be a simple recovery mission. Instead, she uncovers layers of duplicity and conspiracy that pull her into storms, sorcery, and a series of escalating dangers on land and sea.
The first fifty pages left me wondering if I should mark this as DNF. The characters and plot were strong, but the heavy proselytizing and sermonizing were a real turnoff. I am glad I stayed with it, because the religious elements eventually settled into the background and became more thematic than preachy. Once the story gained momentum, I found myself fully invested.
One of my favorite aspects is that the main character is a woman my age. Amina’s adventurous spirit blends naturally with the realities of being a middle-aged mother who carries old wounds, lingering regrets, and a stubborn sense of responsibility. The framing device of Amina dictating her story to a scribe named Jamal adds humor and texture. Their banter interrupts the narrative at just the right moments, reminding the reader that this is a tale being shaped and recorded, not simply lived. It also creates an intriguing tension: we know Amina survives, but we do not yet know what she has…
A
Aleshia (Mad Scibrarian)
October 13, 2025
Verified Purchase
A Sea-Faring Action Adventure with Middle Aged Characters
Amina al-Sirafi is a legendary nakhudha (a ship owner) whose hung-up the seafaring and pirate life. She's middle-aged and has a young daughter and aging mother to care for. Of course, someone with her reputation will be in demand, and a wealthy noblewoman comes knocking at her door one day after tracking her down to ask a favor. The noblewoman's daughter has been kidnapped by the mercenary Frank, Falco Palamenestra. She needs Amina's help to track Falco down and rescue her. She offers Amina a huge reward that will set her family for life; how could she refuse?
It's a slow paced story. It takes it time in setting everything up. Amina has to go collect her crew and intel before she can fully set out to sail on this rescue mission. I really liked this pacing as it gave a lot of time to setup the characters. They each really grew on me, but Amina is my favorite. Amina is a really fun heroine whose experienced and knowledgeable like a legendary captain would be, but also has faults that end up creating obstacles she must overcome.
I also really enjoyed the worldbuilding. It builds up the mythological and fantastical elements to the tale. It creates a world that is part action-adventure, part fairy tale, and part horror, so it checks all the boxes and really meshes well together. I'm definitely looking forward to the next book! And while I've read the first book of the author's other trilogy, I never got around to continue it. Mrs. Chakraborty is a fantastic writer and I really…
What we give up to chase our dreams
A fun and compelling page-turning adventure set in the Indian Ocean a thousand years ago. A lot of historical realism mixed in with myth and magic. I loved seeing an older cast brought out of retirement for "one last" adventure. Expectations are constantly flouted, and problems go deeper than what you thought.
Downsides:
- I found the writing clunky throughout. About once every 20 pages I had to reread a sentence a few times to parse it, pulling me out of the narrative. At first I feared this would stop me from enjoying/finishing the book, but I'm glad to say the story was compelling enough even with this downside.
- Some of the revelations felt too convenient (no spoilers here though). The story is told from Amina's perspective, and I got the sense that if she were really telling the story, she would have divulged certain information earlier, not halfway through the book. It felt a little betraying to finally learn certain things, suggesting the plot could be better done.
- We have a gay character and a trans character, but they feel rather token. Nothing about the plot hinges on these facts, nor anything about the rest of those characters. It's tacked on, and it feels purely like the publisher is trying to hit a quota or "show representation," which is annoying.