Home / Gay / Penalty Shot (Winnipeg Avalanche Hockey Book 3)
Gay

Penalty Shot (Winnipeg Avalanche Hockey Book 3)

Crea Reitan
4.6 / 5.0
Published: 2026

Description

Denny is a man standing on thin ice, both on the rink and in his heart. As a star player for the Winnipeg Avalanche, he is used to high-pressure situations, but nothing prepared him for the sudden, life-altering news that he is going to be a father. Trapped in a complicated arrangement with a woman he barely knows and facing the weight of a future he never planned, Denny finds himself spiraling. He is a struggling soul searching for stability in a world that feels increasingly fragile. Just when he feels like he is losing his grip on everything, he finds an unexpected anchor. What begins as a deep connection between teammates shifts into something profound, challenging the boundaries of their friendship and forcing them to confront the fears they have kept buried. This is a story about the messy, beautiful reality of grief, the terrifying transition into parenthood, and the healing power of love that refuses to quit. This emotional journey balances the intensity of professional hockey with the quiet, aching intimacy of two men finding their way home to each other. It is a heavy, heart-wrenching, and ultimately hopeful tale of courage, growth, and the family we choose when the game changes forever.

Customer Reviews

Top 2 from Amazon
S
Sabrina Diaz
May 7, 2026

So good

Denny has been struggling for a while. When he learns that he is going to be a father, he panics in a number of ways. The days are ticking by closer and closer to when his child will be born. He has to decide what is best for his child’s future, even if that includes him not being in it. But before he can figure it out, the mother of his child, Sally, passes away shortly after childbirth. There is no more figuring out because the moment he sees his son, he knows he loves him. He’ll take care of him. But Denny can’t help but wonder if he is still doing right by him. Then Tyler shows up. Tyler is Sally’s brother. He was on his way to move in with Sally and demand some answers about who she was marrying when he learns she is gone. Tyler always felt like there was something Sally wasn’t saying about her relationship with Denny. And when he tracks Denny down, he has even more questions, because neither of them seem to be in the other’s lives. But that’s something he’ll have to examine later, because all he wants is to be in his nephew’s life. And in doing so, Tyler and Denny realize they need one another in more ways than one. Oof, this story hits you right in the emotions! Both of their lives are turned upside down in many ways. Denny has so much to work through but I loved that he took his responsibilities for his child so seriously in all the ways that mattered. He proved to his friends and himself that him wanting to be a dad now after believing it was something he never…
R
romanticreadsandsuch
May 23, 2026

Penalty Shot

4.25*s This is my first book by Reitan and I’m not sure where to start. There are some trigger warnings so I would make sure that you read those to make sure the book is a good fit. It also discusses kinks pretty bluntly so make sure you’re OK there too. I’m kinda like Tyler, more on the slightly salted vanilla side of things, so while it’s not my thing personally I do appreciate where they are coming from and I feel like Reitan explains things well. She also knows how to deliver the heat because Denny and Tyler are hot together. HAWT hot! While they bring the spice tho they also bring tons of emotions. I mean, Denny hits us right from page one with his guilt and his anxiety and his fear of the future. Then when Sally dies … ooof, it’s a gut punch. But Tyler comes at a time when he’s needed and they slowly get to know one another, drawn together by the miracle of a little boy and the impact from the loss of his mother. And I love them together. I understand their hesitation considering who Sally was but they work together seamlessly. It’s pretty low angst while also being complicated, steeped in the problems that come from childhood trauma. It’s not easy, and probably could have used the advice of a professional, but I do like that all of them are willing to recognize that they may need to explore further to understand who they are. Being my first book there is a lot of history in this world and within this friend group that I don’t know or understand. I enjoyed Denny’s…