Home / Bisexual / I'm Not Scared - Part Two: Masked Men of Fear Island
Bisexual

I'm Not Scared - Part Two: Masked Men of Fear Island

JAYE PRATT
4.8 / 5.0
Published: 2026
Genres

Description

The bridge has been burned, and the fallout is still smoldering. After demanding they exit her life for good, the protagonist finds herself trapped in a suffocating silence of her own making. Walking away was supposed to be the ultimate act of self-preservation—a way to stop diluting her identity to suit the whims of four men who thrive on chaos and blurred lines. Yet, despite the red flags and the emotional wreckage left in their wake, the craving persists. Reconciling desire with safety is a treacherous balancing act. She knows she shouldn’t want them, and she certainly shouldn’t trust them, but the void they left behind is harder to ignore than the danger they represent. As she grapples with whether their bond is truly irreparable or merely scarred, the men are anything but passive. They are lurking in the periphery, refusing to let her go quietly, and the tension is reaching a fever pitch. Caught in this volatile tug-of-war, an unexpected ally emerges from the darkness. The Scarecrow, a figure draped in mystery, might be the only one capable of offering salvation. In a game played with masks and shifting loyalties, she must decide if she’s finally ready to walk away for real—or if she’s drifting deeper into their orbit.

Customer Reviews

Top 5 from Amazon
D
Diana M Martins
May 19, 2026

Scarecrow

This is the second part of what is turning into a deliciously addictive dark journey for me. I’m completely hooked! It picks up right where the cliffhanger left us, in such a stressful moment that had me screaming, “No, no…”, but the cliffhanger in this book made me want to pull my hair out. Still, I’m confident in Scarecrow. In the first book, it was all about finding acceptance and discovering new and exciting things, even with fear getting in the way. In this book, they face fears and emotions head-on, without missing the hilarious and steamy moments. Our MMCs are morally grey, possessive, and total walking red flags — and I think that’s exactly what makes them so captivating, frustrating, and perfect for our FMC. We have an FMC who had to fight for her independence — and she won. She has a strong spirit, but also a huge soft spot for our MMCs, even if it’s easier for her to admit it with some of them than with others. She may not be afraid of the dark, but strong feelings are a completely different story. The distinct personalities of our MMCs and the emotions they awaken in her are something she never expected. I can’t wait for the next book.
S
Sycokittykat - Steff
May 15, 2026

"Everyone here has trauma, and everyone is broken"

Okay I need book three immediately because this cliffhanger was brutal. How am I supposed to sleep after that? I loved the absolutely over top way Vero apologizes. It continues day after day until she has to return to the island...to tell them off...or at least that was what she thought. Kayla is missing her chaotic men. I loved how we got to know the men better. Seeing more of who they each are was enlightening. I was surprised that even Clay was letting her in. We get to meet the scarecrow briefly. He is full of riddles and your answers determine what happens next. I can't wait to get his story. Kayla and the men are finding their way and it's beautiful. She fits in perfectly on the island and finds herself wanting bro leave less and less. Especially when she starts to feel like someone is watching her but that someone doesn't creep like one of her men. When her past shows up things get interesting but if course that's also where we get left dangling. Goid thing we don't have to wait too long because I'm falling for these broken men and I need to see how this goes down.
A
Amber
May 12, 2026

Dark, Chaotic, and Completely Addictive

Part 2 somehow managed to crank the chaos up even higher, and I ate up every second of it. This series has such a wild energy to it. Dark, addictive, emotional, and just unpredictable enough to keep me glued to the page way past bedtime. The character dynamics are what really keep me invested. Watching everyone orbit around Kayla in completely different ways is fascinating, but Vero still owns my heart. Every scene with him hits differently. And Cave? I need answers immediately. There is definitely more to his story, and now I’m desperate to know what’s hiding under the surface. And that ending??? Absolutely criminal. I closed the book and just stared at the wall for a minute. Part 3 cannot come fast enough. My only complaint is that I wanted way more begging after the fallout from Part 1. Kayla deserved at least a little extra groveling before everything moved forward.
B
Brandi S.
May 15, 2026

So Good But That Cliffhanger Wrecked Me!

This book starts by reliving the end of Part One, but through Kayla's POV so we can see what she was thinking in that moment. I liked that we got to see it through her eyes and how she felt about it. I wish there would've been more groveling and that Kayla would've pushed back a little more about what happened. It just seemed a little too fast and easy. We learn more about Kayla and her past, which better explains her behaviour. I loved getting more from Ares in all the ways. He's so peculiar, and I loved seeing his walls come down a little. Brawley and Vero's relationship is just the best, and I love them. Clay is such an alphahole but also so protective. I enjoyed seeing more of the island and people there. I hope there's going to be a lot of books in this series because I'm loving the island, characters, and vibes! I didn't know there was going to be a part three, and so the cliffhanger wrecked me! I need the next book like now lol
C
Christina Hernandez
May 14, 2026

A must read!

I’m Not Scared - Part Two: Masked Men of Fear Island Jaye Pratt - Author ‼️Check Trigger Warnings‼️ ⚠️⚠️⚠️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️ Another cliffhanger! Why are you doing this to me Jaye? I need part three right now. I’m such a big fan of Vero; he might be a little crazy, but he’s incredibly sweet and kindhearted. I love his bond with Brawley, and when Kayla is with the two of them, things really heat up. I’m starting to warm up to Clay, and while Ares is still a bit of a mystery, the one I’m most curious about is Crave. I can’t get enough of these books. I need more. I’m Not Scared – Part Two: Masked Men of Fear Island comes out on May 13, and it’s one you won’t want to miss.