Home / Lesbian / I Shouldn't Want Her: Lesbian First Time Short Story (Lesbian Women Romance Stories Bundle)
Lesbian

I Shouldn't Want Her: Lesbian First Time Short Story (Lesbian Women Romance Stories Bundle)

Julia Young
4.6 / 5.0
Published: 2026

Description

Seeking refuge from a painful breakup, a young woman retreats to a secluded cabin, hoping for nothing more than a weekend of silence and solitude. The last thing she anticipates is finding herself hopelessly drawn to Joss, the steady, compassionate older sister of the ex she is trying to forget. Joss has always been the anchor in the chaos—the one who offered solace when everything else fell apart. Now, within the quiet confines of the cabin, their long-standing friendship begins to shimmer with a new, undeniable tension. What begins as a platonic escape quickly shifts into a dance of lingering glances and unspoken desires. While the realities of her unfinished past wait for her back in the city—boxes on the floor and a life left in limbo—the magnetism between them makes it impossible to think about anything but the present moment. In this intimate story of self-discovery and unexpected longing, two women find themselves standing on the precipice of a connection that defies expectations. Forced to choose between the safety of their old lives and the thrill of a new beginning, they must decide if the spark igniting between them is worth destroying the boundaries they’ve carefully built.