Home / Lesbian / For the First Time: A sapphic small town secret love/first love romance set in the 90's (Paige Point Book 1)
Lesbian

For the First Time: A sapphic small town secret love/first love romance set in the 90's (Paige Point Book 1)

Rebecca Dayle
4.6 / 5.0
Published: 2026

Description

Paige Point, Wyoming, is the kind of place where every secret is gossiped over and every deviation from the norm is scrutinized. Tess Daniels, having recently returned from a stint in New York, feels like an outsider in her own hometown. She has always felt disconnected from the relentless romantic chatter of her peers, assuming she is simply broken—until a chance encounter at a bonfire flips her world upside down. Enter Katy Werner, a newcomer with an effortless confidence and a gaze that catches Tess off guard. As an undeniable, magnetic pull develops between them, Tess is forced to confront the truth: the spark she thought she lacked has been there all along, just waiting for the right person to ignite it. However, in a town defined by suffocating expectations and prying eyes, their burgeoning connection feels both exhilarating and terrifyingly hazardous. Set against the rugged, dusty backdrop of the 1990s, this is a story of first discovery and the courage required to be yourself when the world demands conformity. Tess and Katy must navigate the treacherous waters of small-town judgment, learning that some sparks are too bright to be hidden in the shadows. For the First Time is a tender, slow-burn exploration of love, identity, and the bravery of holding on.

Customer Reviews

Top 5 from Amazon
H
Hunter99
January 31, 2026
Verified Purchase

Love at first, blush.

This book makes me remember when I was younger and just figuring stuff out. How do I feel? do I does she... All the feels ( and butterflies)! It's wonderful! I love the time period, I love the dual dialogue of both women's perspective and they are very different but complementary. It's a wonderful read.
A
Amazon Customer
April 29, 2026

Unexpected

I didn’t expect the way this book was written and never have o read a book written quite like it but it was unexpectedly refreshing. The way the main character is also the writer is a fresh take on storytelling. This book didn’t disappoint and I’m hoping the second book which is basically the next chapter continues to impress and carry me through Tess and Katy’s world because diving into them has been one of the better books I’ve read this year. If you pick it up it definitely won’t disappoint you, it may frustrate you and give you a vast amount of emotions but it definitely will keep you hooked.
K
Kindle Customer
January 31, 2026

Fall in love!!

I went into reading this book thinking "some light reading for a glue January day". I came away having fallen in love with book characters! The fact that it has taken this long for a relatable storyline for those of us in same sex relationships always baffled me. The thing was, they were waiting for Rebecca Dayne to write it! This new author came right out of the gate with a winner. The book is for EVERYONE, but feeling included for once is definitely the cherry on top! Loved the perspective writing style and thankfully book 2 is done, or our girl would have left us hanging for more! So make sure you buy both!!!
A
alba
February 18, 2026

Lovely and captivating

I purchased this book from the author personally. I love the author writing style that kept me engaged from start to finish. I can't wait to read the second book.
D
Deefromthehill
January 31, 2026

This book grabs you right from the start!

WOW! I absolutely loved this book! The author has a fantastic writing style that kept me engaged from start to finish! The characters are well developed and the plot is captivating! I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fun playful and exciting read!